Showing posts with label Gayfer's. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gayfer's. Show all posts

11 January 2025

Springdale Mall, Mobile, AL

 A dead mall


My only experiences in Alabama’s oldest city involved brief stays at their airport which itself reminded me of a retro mall with its red brick walls, large court area in the center, and lofty ceilings.  However, like most shopping malls with the same features, the terminal will soon be replaced.  Just down the road on Airport Boulevard sits the main retail district of the Port City.  At the southeastern quadrant of the thoroughfare’s crossing with I-65 lies its first enclosed shopping complex, The Shoppes at Bel Air.  And just across the street is what used to be its main indoor rival, Springdale Mall.


1- The early Springdale Plaza.  2- McRae’s at Springdale Plaza under construction.  3 & 4- Interior shots of early mall (Source for all)

Springdale was what I refer to as a “walkthrough” mall, one where an anchor has to be traversed to reach another indoor corridor.  But there was just something about Springdale that I always admired, more so than its competitor with its earlier and simpler barbell design, and I wish I would have paid it a visit before all of the enclosed common areas were slowly eliminated over the years.

Springdale Mall lease plan ca. 1975.  View the full PDF version here.

Springdale Plaza opened in 1959 as an open air collection of shops, one of the first built within the city at the time.  WT Grant and JCPenney anchored the facility at its opening with Mobile based Gayfer’s department store debuting their flagship location at the midpoint of the center a year later.  Less than a decade later in 1967 its cross street rival, known as Bel Air Mall at the time, opened its doors.

Springdale Mall lease plan ca. 1990.  View the full PDF version here.

Responding to the appearance of this formidable competitor as well as its first expansion in 1974 poaching JCPenney from their lineup, Springdale Plaza embarked on an expansion of its own.  An indoor corridor of smaller specialty shops was added just to the east of Gayfer’s with Montgomery Ward anchoring the opposite end.  In 1984, McRae’s added their nameplate to the façade with the opening of their freestanding outlet to the west of Gayfer’s in 1984.


1 to 3- Interior shots of the enclosure before closing. (Source for all)  4- Lonely public telephones in the eastern mall. (Source)

In the latter part of the decade, Montgomery Ward downsized their footprint at Springdale Mall by subleasing the northwestern corner of their building to Toy R Us.  The following year a second indoor concourse was added to the west of the main facility connecting McRae’s and Gayfer’s.  At the same time, Gayfer’s expanded their store by nearly 200,000 square feet to serve as their main flagship location.

Springdale lease plan ca. 2003.  View the full PDF version here.

However, this time at peak indoor shopping mall didn’t last long for the already forty year old facility.  The nineties brought the skyrocketing ascension of what was already a fairly old retail concept- the big box.  Beginning in the middle of this decade the center’s new owners, CBL and Associates of Chattanooga, started the gradual process of powercenter-ing what was by then simply called Springdale.  Old Navy and Barnes & Noble were among the first to move in.

Springdale lease plan ca. 2007.  View the full PDF version here.

CBL and Associates also completed the first major refresh of Springdale’s interior corridors.  Even with these expenditures, however, it was apparent that Springdale was losing the enclosed retail destination game to its seemingly ever-expanding competitor across the street.  Drastic changes were needed; and while at first the big boxes were finding homes in the exterior facing portions, demalling to make additional space was inevitable.


1- The Belk exterior. (Source)  2 to 4- the closed Springdale Cinemas, Best Buy and Old Navy outlets at Springdale. (Source for all)

Dillard’s, with a takeover of the Mobile-based brand and all of their branches, took over the 280,000 square foot Gayfer’s flagship in 1998.  But the Little Rock-based department store only lasted until 2003 when they bolted for, with absolutely no one surprised, Bel Air Mall.  Almost immediately, the one time flagship was darkened, closed, and unceremoniously demolished.  Today a Sam’s Club resides on the pad.


Springdale pamphlet ca. 2011.  View the full PDF version here.

More changes came in 1999 when Montgomery Ward shuttered their outlet allowing Burlington Coat Factory to move in not long after.  But bigger revisions were to follow as the newer western enclosed concourse was eliminated in 2001 and reconfigured to house Best Buy.  In 2006 McRae’s was rebranded as Belk while the larger eastern enclosed mall was being chipped away at piece by piece to accommodate more big boxes.


1- The former east mall entrance. (Source)  2- Springdale today. (Source)  3- Sam’s Club, built where Gayfer’s flagship used to stand. (Source)  4- Burlington’s outlet in the old Montgomery Ward space. (Source)

By the 2010s Springdale no longer contained any more interior concourses and ceased to be an enclosed shopping mall.  The power center assimilation was complete and the Port City was down to only a single enclosed retail destination, most than likely never to see another built.

Springdale Plaza lease plan ca. 2024.  View the full PDF version here.

13 May 2013

Santa Rosa Mall, Mary Esther, FL

A dead mall

-UPDATE BELOW-
14 September 2024


Truth be told, I was never much of a fan of the Gulf Coast. Having grown up in other oceanside cities, I thought that the "redneck riviera" coastline must pale in comparison to the beaches of California, Hawai'i and the Atlantic Seaboard. It only took one visit to Destin, Florida to change my opinion completely.



-UPDATE-  1- Santa Rose Mall’s original main entrance.  2- The final touches are being made before the mall opening.  3 & 4- Original anchor Gayfer’s exterior and interior entrances.  5 & 6- The crowds arrive soon after the grand opening.  (Source for all)

I must have visited my sister at least a dozen times when she was living in the Fort Walton Beach area while stationed at Eglin Air Force Base. We made side treks to the town of Seaside, the planned community where The Truman Show was filmed, as well as to Pensacola Beach just to the west. But, during those many visits, I think that we may have gone to the city's only enclosed shopping center, Santa Rosa Mall, once or twice.

-UPDATE-  Santa Rosa Mall lease plan ca. 1978. View the full PDF version here.

Santa Rosa Mall didn’t make much of an impression on me.  During my visit(s) in the early 2000s, it was decked out just like many other of its peers with white ceramic tile floors, pastel mauve and blue highlights with a basic drop ceiling held up by basic circular columns.  I did like the curvy ceiling elements, but that really was about it.

Santa Rosa Mall Mallmanac ca. 2000. View the full PDF version here.

Santa Rosa Mall opened in 1976 as a basic, straight-line facility with three anchors.  Sears and JCPenney made their homes at either end while Gayfer's held the middle spot.  A new wing with a food court and a fourth anchor, McRae's, was added in 1984 between Gayfer’s and Sears.  Later that decade, however, Gayfer’s was taken over by Dillard’s while McRae’s soon saw the nameplate for Belk over its doors.



-UPDATE-  1- The main entrance.  2- Santa Rosa Mall from above.  3- The Sears store.  4- The former Belk, the newest anchor and the first to close. (Source for 1 to 4)  5- The JCPenney building. (Source)  6- Dillard’s. (Source)

Since my last visit in 2004, there has been a building boom of new retail facilities in Okaloosa County, most of them open-air to capitalize on the region's sub-tropical climate. All of these are filled with businesses aimed at the many vacationers who make their way to the Emerald Coast each year.  Santa Rosa Mall, containing nothing distinguishing itself from any other mall in the region, fills the needs of the local population fairly well, but not much else. But, yeah, at least they had mallmanacs.

-UPDATE-  Santa Rosa Mall lease plan ca. 2013. View the full PDF version here.


-UPDATE-

-10 February 2024

Santa Rosa Mall Mallmanac ca. 2018. View the full PDF version here.

Not long after my original post, the pieces started falling in place for Santa Rosa Mall’s decline.  In 2013, Belk announced that it was shuttering their location, the facility’s newest anchor.  In December, their pad at the end of the 1984 expansion wing was darkened.  Subsequently, many of the smaller stores occupying that concourse left as well.



1- One of the many empty storefronts at Santa Rosa Mall. (Source)  2- Center court hosting a community event.  3- The Dillard’s mall entrance.  4- The JCPenney interior opening.  5- Sears before their closing.  6- Though community events still bring in the crowds, there’s not a whole lot else.  (Source for 2 to 6.)

Former national juggernauts Sears and JCPenney announced their departures in 2018 and 2020, respectively, while the former Belk was demolished in 2019.  After first downgrading their store to an outlet location, Dillard’s called it quits in 2023, leaving Santa Rosa Mall anchorless.  New apartments have been built where Belk used to stand and there are plans for more, but today Okaloosa County’s only enclosed shopping center sits empty and dead.

Santa Rosa Mall Mallmanac ca. 2023. View the full PDF version here.

04 May 2013

Orlando Fashion Square, Orlando, FL

A dead mall

-UPDATE BELOW-
9 February 2023


When we lived in the Orlando suburb of Winter Park in 1985, we were in equal proximity to three first generation malls. First, there was Winter Park Mall, the one that we least went to. Second, there was Colonial Plaza, the old mall that seemed to have been around forever and looked it. Finally, there was the Orlando Fashion Square, the large and super modern, ready for the eighties mega-mall. At the time, this latest of the three was the king of the central Florida retail scene.

1- Orlando Fashion Square lease plan ca. 1975. View the full PDF version here.
2- Orlando Fashion Square lease plan ca. 1988. View the full PDF version here.

Sears was where our military, blue collar family preferred to shop as there was no Montgomery Ward nearby. I remember getting my first pair of Velcro sneakers there, a marine blue pair of Converse. I was so proud of those ugly shoes. And Sears had toys, as well. All kinds of stuff to keep a kid happy. But, as much as I loved spending time with my hoot of a grandmother, I really disliked going to the mall with her. She was all about some Robinson's and Burdine's and would spend hours browsing its fashions. I just saw both damn places as an endless seas of boring clothes. I remember sitting outside of the Robinson's for what seemed like hours with my older brother just waiting for her to finish shopping.


Orlando Fashion Square Mallmanac ca. 1990. View the full PDF version here.

And what a seating area it was. For some reason, I remember the mall common area right outside of the Robinson's and later Maison Blanche better than any other part of Orlando Fashion Square. The ceilings were at least 30 feet high, and above the entrance to the anchor I remember moody dark glass windows. I was just so fascinated by this feature. Maybe it was just my own boredom. Or maybe I'm just getting old and not remembering things exactly the way they really were.


-UPDATE- 1 & 2- The Sears store around the opening of Orlando Fashion Square.  3 & 4- The Burdine’s and Robinson’s mall entrances.

Having opened in 1973, Orlando Fashion Square was a youthful 12 years old when we moved to greater Orlando. Though not a whole lot younger than Colonial Plaza just down the road, it always seemed to be the much cooler of the two. It was where the younger crowd hung out and there was quite a bit of focus on the teenage set. But, truth be told, being the budding retail and architecture nerd that I was, I always found Colonial Plaza, as a whole, to be much more interesting.


Orlando Fashion Square Mallmanac ca. 1997. View the full PDF version here.

We left Winter Park later that year for Virginia Beach and didn't return until 1989. By that time, a lot was going on at Orlando Fashion Square. It's trade area dominance was being challenged by the brand new Florida Mall, a huge super-regional located on the south side of town close to International Drive. Orlando Fashion Square responded by embarking on an expansion that focused on the Maison Blanche area. A new store was built abutting the older store just to the northeast. Then, the existing store was converted into a two level concourse of shops with theaters and a food court on the upper level. I remember that the new Maison Blanche opened well before the mall section, and there was a long tunnel that had to be traversed through the construction zone connecting the existing mall to the new anchor. It was cool and all, but I was saddened to see my favorite feature of the mall, the entrance to Maison Blanche, removed.


-UPDATE- 1- The roadside sign for Orlando Fashion Square.  2- Dillard’s exterior.  3- An outside entrance for Macy’s.  4- The façade of the cineplex. (Source for all)

Since that visit in 1989, there have been even more changes. The long running nameplates of Maison Blanche and Burdine's have been replaced by Dillard's and Macy's, respectively. The retail strip on Colonial Drive is definitely showing its age and of those three mid-eighties malls that we frequented, only Orlando Fashion Square remains. New malls such as Oviedo Marketplace, Mall at Millenia and West Oaks continue to erode the mall's target audience, but its proximity to the older and affluent suburb of Winter Park with its stable and dense population should keep the mall afloat for years to come. Hopefully.



-UPDATE-

-2 February 2025


I feel like I’m getting pretty repetitive with these updates.  I’m finding it increasingly difficult to find new ways of saying this mall is now dead.  And while Orlando Fashion Square remains the sole enclosed shopping mall in the inner ring suburbs of Orlando’s east side, the past few years have not been kind.


1- JCPenney from the first floor.  The store is now vacant.  2- Sears mall entrance, now closed and the building demolished.  3- Dillard’s Clearance outlet’s now shuttered interior entrance although the first level of the anchor remains occupied.  4- Macy’s, the only remaining traditional department store at Orlando Fashion Square. (Source for all)

Just a year after my original post, the Dillard’s store, part of the early nineties expansion and previously labeled as Maison Blanche and Gayfer’s, shuttered their upper level and became a clearance outlet.  This left a darkened anchor entrance on the miniscule upper level and smaller mall retailers, especially those located on that tier, were soon to follow.


Orlando Fashion Square pamphlet ca. 2019. View the full PDF version here.

Sears, which opened as a free-standing entity ten years before the balance of Orlando Fashion Square’s corridors, departed in 2016.  The following year their building, the oldest on the property, was demolished to make way for a smaller complex to house big box stores.


1- Orlando Fashion Square lease plan ca. 2021. View the full PDF version here.
2- Orlando Fashion Square lease plan ca. 2023. View the full PDF version here.

JCPenney vacated their location, which was added as a part of the early nineties expansion, in late 2020.  This left the mall with only one full-line department store anchor, Macy’s.  At the same time, the Dillard’s Clearance outlet remains as well.



Orlando Fashion Square’s mainly empty interior concourses. (Source for all)

In the years since, there has been an exodus of smaller retailers.  Future plans involving a mixed-use community of residences, offices and retailers have been announced, but Orlando Fashion Square remains to this day just as it always has, a single use enclosed shopping mall, though without the shoppers.